I’ve not tried the holdalls, and they are expensive, but the shimano aspire carryall I bought when my tournament fell apart is excellent. Holds loads of gear, the most comfy strap I have come across too, and I love the way it’s all held open at the top with plastic strengtheners. I’ll be investing in the holdall too when money allows. The zips are great too.
I have a sensas pro ready rod holdall, the material is great because it’s wipe clean. I find the waterproof zips rather stiff to open and close, and to be fair it weights half a ton empty. But it’s build to last a long while.